BG:Noted Idea of public ideas

Jump to: navigation, search
Title Public Idea
Type change request
Severity 3-normal
Keywords Layout, Idea creation
Date (expected, solved,...)
Expected Version "v2.52" is not in the list of possible values (v0.8, v0.9, v1.0, v1.1, v1.2, v1.5, v2.0, v2.1, v2.2, v2.3, v2.4, v2.5, v2.6, v2.7, v2.8, v2.9, v3.0, v3.1, v3.2, v3.3, v3.5, v4.0, v4.1) for this property.
Status Solved&Tested
Summary (1-2 lines): Creates a list of all noted public ideas
Test Procedure: create an idea, -> convert it to public -> should be shown in the list
News: Comany name are missing in Stck market

this page was created by Special:FormEdit/BugReport, and can be edited by Special:FormEdit/BugReport/BG:Noted Idea of public ideas. See all change requests/bug reports at BugReport or, sorted after version number in Movation:Innobors_Version.

Bug 25th June 2012

See the file In Stock Market _ Company Name missing 20120625 sent by e-mail.

Update 8.May 2012

The old term "noted idea" is obsolete and replaced by public idea.

Updated 12. April 2012

As of now we have so few "public ideas". Thus all ideas ("public" and "listed") are listed on the "Stock Market" (thus we develop the "public page", but leave it visible only for admin)


Updated 9. April 2012

The old "only ideas ready for scoring are listed" is dismissed, as it is obsolete

  • listed ideas carries all ideas which have "payed 25.000 NOK" and thus are able for the scorecard process
  • public ideas carries all ideas which have been published as "public", and have payed 2500 NOK.
  • all other ideas are privat, and are only listed on the user's own page (my ideas)

Update 6.4.2012

lists only public ideas, not private ideas. That means the idea owner can register an idea, but than has to make it "public" and pay 2500 NOK for getting the idea listed as a public idea.

  • private ideas should only be visible on the "my pages" from the idea owner. (they are really private)

updated 8.2.2012

Description of the noted idea (page 4)

This is a page which represents all ideas which are public, but which are not ready for the InnoBors. Here users/visitors should be able to "thumb up" and to provide comments.

The owner of the idea will have the opportunity to invite people to his team, and to upgrade the idea to a "listed idea" on the InnoBors, thus enbling the RSI scoring.



  • Remove companies from the list of choices
  • Please use the common header and footer pages

Related items

Understanding and Discussion

Josef: See above

Tawhid: Can you explain little bit more about this issue? Currently only "Listed" ideas are displayed under stock market tab and all ideas are displayed under idea management tab according to the Eric's specification.

According to BG:Idea Creation-01, we will have three categories for ideas

  • a private idea being only visible to the user - "nowhere in the system except on the user page (my ideas)". Needs to be "upgrade to noted" or "upgrade to listed" (through "my ideas") ---NEW: upgrade from "private" to "noted & listed" should be allowed (costs 27500 NOK)
  • a Noted idea is available for all community members, and will be presented in the "Noted Ideas" page BG:Noted Idea-01. Owners of these ideas have the ability to "upgrade to listed" idea---noted ideas are shown in page-2, right? NO, noted ideas will appear on an own page, see BG:Noted Idea. I often call the noted ideas "page 4".
  • a listed idea is on the InnoBors and a candidate for getting rated.---are the listed ideas are shown in the stock market page? YES, correct, these ones are on page 2 "Stock Market"


please add your understanding of the specifications here, including modules being affected


please add your suggestion for implementation



Old info

Updated 8.Feb2012

This is the "old description" on how to handle listed ideas.

Only ideas which "are ready for scoring" shall be listed - now I see that all ideas are listed, even though they are just ideas (and not taken up on the stock exchange).

Related Topics